Holiday Inn Express Never Lies to You

$80 in Antwerp, $250 in Ghent. What the extra money buys, what it doesn’t, and why the cheap hotel never disappoints.

Sunset over a square in Antwerp, with trams and buses below
Antwerp, Belgium, from our room in the Holiday Inn Express

This fall we paid $80 a night for a Holiday Inn Express in Antwerp, which is not a cheap city. Now we’ve moved on to a Marriott in Ghent at $250. We’re here because the location is perfect and I need the elite nights to keep Marriott Titanium status. Same country, same two people, three times the price.

The Marriott is better, and I’ll concede that up front. In Antwerp, when Lisa and I passed each other in the room, one of us turned sideways. In Ghent nobody turns sideways. The room is bigger, the bed is better, and the place feels like somewhere you chose rather than somewhere you ended up.

Is it three times better? It’s worth about twice as much. I can’t name anything the last third bought me. As I write this, we can hear the family in the next room. Their children are very young, and they do a fair amount of crying and screaming. The extra $170 a night didn’t buy a thicker wall.

The blueprint

Every hotel room on earth is built from the same parts: a door, a bed, a bathroom (yours or down the hall), and, if you’re lucky, a window. That holds for the Ibis box and for the suite at the top of the tower. Add a front desk and a lobby and you have most of what a hotel does.

Call it 85 percent. The Holiday Inn Express delivers all of it and throws in breakfast.

Everything above that is the last 15 percent: the larger room, the heavier linens, the lobby that smells of something expensive, the staff who greet you by name, the chocolate on the pillow. The price curve behaves strangely there. The first 85 percent is cheap. The last 15 costs everything. When you pay two, three, or five times the base rate, most of the difference is buying that sliver.

The Holiday Inn Express charges you nothing for the 15 percent and delivers nothing. So it never disappoints you. Check-in is quick, the room is what the photos showed, the breakfast is where they said it would be. The promise is small and they keep it every time.

The franchise rulebook helps, but it isn’t why this works. Budget hotels all over the world deliver the same basics, plenty of them family operations with a single location. At the bottom of the market the expectations are few and everyone knows them: a clean room, a decent bed, hot water, a lock that works. A hotel that misses those gets torched in online reviews, and people stop booking it. The market enforces the basics more reliably than any franchise manual could.

What the curve actually buys

The first step up buys real things: more space and a better mattress. It’s supposed to buy quiet too. Soundproofing may be the most important feature a hotel room has. It appears in no listing photo anywhere, and Ghent is proof that paying more doesn’t guarantee it.

It’s the next step where the returns flatten. From $250 to $1,000 and beyond, the room is barely larger and the bed barely better. What’s left to buy is ceremony: the welcome drink, the three people who greet you at the door, the pillow menu, the lengthy explanation of the lighting system.

Ceremony is the part that breaks.

The lighting system they spent so long explaining doesn’t work, and neither do the electronic curtains. The car will be out front at 9 AM, and it isn’t. The car meeting you at the airport isn’t there either. The internet will be fixed this afternoon, and it isn’t. The chef has a special dessert for you, and nobody mentions it again. The restaurant tables reserved for elites go to whoever walks in. Turndown happens every other night.

We spend 365 nights a year in hotels and Airbnbs, and our status gets us upgraded to suites often enough that we see the whole range, from the Ibis to the top of the market. What I’ve noticed is that the expensive stays frustrate me more often than the cheap ones. Partly that’s because they make more promises, so there’s more to miss. Mostly it’s because I paid for them not to.

It doesn’t take a luxury hotel, either. Any upgrade is a promise. In Panama City we checked into a Hampton Inn in the center of town and were upgraded to a suite. It was a nice suite. It was also directly under the pool deck, and that night there was a party. The music was loud enough that the room vibrated, and it kept us up all night.

The next day the manager came up to talk with us about it. While she was standing in the room, the music came back on. The bass thumped through the ceiling, and nobody needed to explain anything further.

“Please move us to a standard room,” we said.

They put us in one on a lower floor, and it was a relief. It was the 85 percent, delivered as promised. The suite was the 15, and the 15 was the part that broke.

The fear is rational

A bad night, for us, is one of 365. There’s always another hotel, another meal, another flight. For someone taking one trip a year, a bad night on a ten-night vacation is ten percent of the vacation. The whole family may be along. It may be the anniversary trip. Nobody wants to be the person who booked the place with the bugs.

So people pick the brand name over the independent, and the expensive brand over the cheap one. Part of that is fear, and part is aspiration. On vacation, most people want to stay somewhere nicer than home. A temporary upgrade to your life is a reasonable thing to spend money on.

The fear is rational, and so is wanting insurance against it. Our stakes are low, and it’s easy to hand out advice to people whose stakes are high. Whether the premium actually buys the protection it’s selling is a separate question.

Insurance with an undisclosed failure rate

I’ve read enough policies to know that having coverage and getting a claim paid are two different things.

The luxury premium is a policy with no printed exclusions and no published failure rate, and the premium is collected either way. People book the Four Seasons to buy their way to safety. Sometimes they do.

What fails is almost always something you can’t photograph: air, water, temperature, noise, smell. The air conditioner that doesn’t cool, the shower with no pressure, the hot water that comes and goes, the staff smoking under your open window, with the smoke drifting up into the room. None of it shows up in the listing, and none of it is priced when you book.

In July we were in Barcelona for the opening stages of the Tour de France, paying Tour de France rates for a new hotel in the middle of a heat wave. A sign in the lobby announced that rooms would go no lower than 22 degrees Celsius (about 72°F), and in that heat they never got close. We spent the nights without so much as a sheet on us.

These things fail at every price point. The difference is that the expensive hotel charged you to believe they wouldn’t. Paying more buys less protection than you’d hope.

You could build a screening routine for all this. We don’t have one. We stay in too many places, too often, and too far off the usual routes for rules to work, and often there’s nothing else to choose. What works for us is flexibility. Things happen. We know we’re leaving soon, and it’ll be a good story.

The best case against me

Nobody books an Aman to rent a room. They’re buying a place they don’t leave, and the whole trip is arranged around it. Measured that way, my 85 percent is irrelevant, because the room was never the product.

It’s also fair to say I’ve built this argument on the mushy middle. Ritz-Carlton and the other chain luxury brands run scripted service across hundreds of properties, and that’s where ceremony is most likely to wobble. The small top-tier operators are a different business, and I can’t tell you how often they fail.

And variance cuts both ways. One of my favorite sunrises anywhere was over the Annapurna range in Nepal, from a hotel we chose for that view and paid a little extra for. What made it worth it was location, not service or linens. That’s a different 15 percent from the pillow menu.

I have paid for it. In Sydney we stayed at the Park Hyatt, in a room looking out at the Opera House and the harbor. Every morning we ate breakfast in the dining room, and that time of year the sun rose directly behind the Opera House. For a few minutes, it’s the photograph everyone comes for. Then the sun clears the roof and lands in your eyes. We ate excellent omelets and croissants squinting, and got out of there as fast as we could.

Even the view has fine print. It’s still the 15 percent I’d pay for.

Know which trip you’re on

Spend the money when you know what it’s buying.

If your goal is a place you never leave, the resort is correctly priced and none of this applies to you. If it’s a view, pay for the view and skip the marble. If you’re in Delhi or Mumbai and what you need when you get back each night is a sealed, cool, quiet room that is exactly what you expected, you’re buying control, and a good chain hotel sells that at nearly every price point, crying toddlers next door notwithstanding. If what you need is a clean bed and a base for exploring a city, you’re buying the box, and the box is cheap.

Most people never ask which trip they’re on. So they buy the expensive answer to a question they haven’t posed.

Towels

In Amman, Jordan, we booked The Art Hotel, which the New York Times had recommended in one of its 36 Hours pieces, so it seemed like safe ground. We stayed longer than 36 hours. Maybe that was the mistake.

Things went fine until the day the room was cleaned and no towels came back. We called the front desk. A man came up carrying two bath mats. We explained, politely, that we needed towels. He was exasperated. “Towels, towels,” he said. “Everybody wants towels.”

The market enforces the basics at the bottom. A hotel with a Times write-up has other ways to fill its rooms.

We’ve told that story a thousand times. The worst hotels make the best stories, and they’re a large share of what we remember from all these years on the road.

The Holiday Inn Express in Antwerp will never give us one. That’s what the $80 paid for.